Private student loans tend to arrive with a particular kind of mail: a statement from a lender you did not choose, an interest rate that rose after graduation, and no income driven plan to fall back on. If you have been told that private student loans can never be discharged, or that they are just like credit cards, I understand the confusion. Neither statement is right.

"Private" does not automatically mean dischargeable, and it does not automatically mean protected. The answer depends on what the loan paid for, where you went to school, and what the promissory note says. Here is how I sort that out.

Can private student loans be discharged in bankruptcy?

Some can, in an ordinary Chapter 7 or Chapter 13, with no separate lawsuit. Others can be discharged only by proving undue hardship, the same standard that applies to federal loans. The dividing line is 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(8), which lists the kinds of education debt that are not discharged unless repaying them would be an undue hardship.

For a loan from a private bank or lender, the category that usually matters is a qualified education loan, as the Internal Revenue Code defines it in section 221(d). If a private loan meets that definition, it is protected unless you prove undue hardship. If it does not, and no other part of § 523(a)(8) applies, it is generally treated like other unsecured debt and discharged with everything else.

What is a qualified education loan?

In plain terms, it is a loan taken solely to pay the cost of attending an eligible school, for an eligible student, within a reasonable time of when the costs were incurred. Each piece of that has a specific meaning.

  • Eligible school. Generally a college, university, or vocational school that is eligible to participate in the federal student aid programs under Title IV of the Higher Education Act.
  • Cost of attendance. The expenses the school itself sets as the cost of attendance, such as tuition, fees, books, and room and board, reduced by scholarships and other tax-free aid.
  • Eligible student. Generally a student enrolled at least half time in a program that leads to a degree, certificate, or other recognized credential.
  • Solely for those costs. The loan has to have been taken to pay qualified education expenses, not mixed with other purposes.

A loan that refinances a qualified education loan is generally also treated as a qualified education loan, so refinancing an old private loan does not, by itself, change the answer.

Which private loans may not qualify?

These are the patterns I look for. None of them is automatic, and each one depends on the documents.

  • Loans for programs at schools that are not eligible for federal aid. Many flight schools, coding bootcamps, and some trade and certificate programs fall in this group.
  • Loans for more than the cost of attendance. A private loan that was larger than the school's cost of attendance, after other aid, may not qualify.
  • Loans to a student who was not an eligible student, such as someone enrolled less than half time.
  • Loans for purposes beyond school, such as bar study loans, relocation loans, or residency loans taken after the degree was finished.
  • Loans that were marketed as student loans but were in substance personal loans, paid to the borrower directly with no school certification.

When a private loan falls outside the definition, it may be discharged in the ordinary Chapter 7 without an adversary proceeding. Before I tell a client that, I review the promissory note, the school's eligibility, the disbursement records, and the cost of attendance for the period. Lenders often describe every loan they make as nondischargeable. The law does not.

What did the Tenth Circuit decide about private student loans?

Lenders have sometimes argued that any private student loan is protected under a different part of § 523(a)(8), the one covering an obligation to repay funds received as an educational benefit. In McDaniel v. Navient Solutions, decided in 2020, the Tenth Circuit rejected that reading. The court held that the phrase does not sweep in private student loans generally. Colorado is in the Tenth Circuit, so that decision governs here.

McDaniel did not make all private loans dischargeable. A private loan that is a qualified education loan is still protected. A private loan made under a program funded or guaranteed by a government unit or a nonprofit institution can also be protected under another part of the statute. What McDaniel did was close a door lenders had used to claim protection for loans that do not fit those categories.

Does the DOJ attestation process apply to private student loans?

No. The attestation process that began in November 2022 is guidance for Department of Justice attorneys representing the Department of Education. It governs how the federal government responds to a request to discharge a federal loan. A private lender is not bound by it, and has no obligation to follow it.

So if your private loan is a qualified education loan, discharging it means an undue hardship case against the private lender, decided under the Brunner test as the Tenth Circuit applies it in Colorado. The lender decides for itself whether to contest the case, negotiate, or settle. Some do settle. Some contest everything. That uncertainty is part of what I weigh with you before recommending this path. For the federal side, see can federal student loans be discharged in bankruptcy.

Is bankruptcy the right tool for a newer private loan?

It can be. For a conventional private loan from a Title IV school, taken out for tuition and taken a few years ago, the undue hardship standard is usually hard to meet so soon after graduation. In that situation, a bankruptcy adversary proceeding will likely not provide full discharge, but it does give us an opportunity to negotiate with the lender. This can result in more favorable payment terms, including interest and principal reduction, fixed monthly payments, and partial forgiveness.

If the lender sues to collect, that is not the end of the conversation. A collection lawsuit is a point where negotiation is often possible again, based on your finances at that time. If the private loan is one part of a larger stack of debt, bankruptcy may still make sense for everything else, even if the private loan survives it. Whether you qualify for Chapter 7 depends on the Colorado means test.

What happens to my cosigner if I file bankruptcy?

Your cosigner is still liable for the loan balance, unless we negotiate their release as part of a settlement. A bankruptcy discharge only releases the person who filed. Under 11 U.S.C. § 524(e), it does not affect anyone else's obligation on the same debt. If the private loan is discharged for you, or simply not paid, the lender can pursue your cosigner, who is often a parent or grandparent. In a Chapter 13, the co-debtor stay can protect the cosigner from collection while the plan is in place, but it does not erase the cosigner's obligation.

If someone you love cosigned, I know that is often the hardest part of this decision. It is worth knowing early, so you can talk with them before the lender does.

If you have private student loans and are not sure which kind you have, my team and I can review the documents with you. The paid Strategy Session is where I tell you plainly whether bankruptcy reaches the loan, and when it does not, what I would do instead.